American Turf Magazine
View Cart
0 item, $0.00

Jun 17, 2004



The story did not get much media attention, so in case you missed it, Roy Chapman, the

owner of Smarty Jones, ripped Jerry Bailey last Saturday at Churchill Downs.

Chapman, his wife Pat, and trainer John Servis were at Churchill to formally accept the

Kentucky Derby trophy, an obviously festive event.

Instead Chappy took the occasion to lay the lumber on Bailey for Jerry"s Belmont performance

on Eddington.

I"ve been in this game a while, and I don"t ever recall seeing or hearing the owner of a beaten

horse blame a rival jockey for the defeat.

According to my sources, this is what Chappy told the cameras and microphones:

"I never saw two riders (obviously Bailey and Solis) ride so hard to lose a race in my life. They just

were out for one thing: making sure Smarty didn"t win.

"It was very obvious what happened. Those riders were not out to win the race. They were out to

ruin the race. I"ve met an awful lot of people who said the same thing. Every jockey I"ve ever

hired, I hired to win a race.

"(Bailey and Solis) were not out to win the race."

Interesting stuff.

And what makes it more interesting is that Bailey was at Churchill that day to ride Peace Rules in the

Stephen Foster, so it was a simple thing for the media to ask him for a response to Chapman"s charges.

Said Bailey:

"I"m sorry that Mr. Chapman feels that way. All I can say is that I said going into the race that Eddington

trained like that. We felt like if my horse goes 12s (12-second furlongs), he had a chance. That"s what we

were trying to do.

"I"ve been asked if I tried to get Smarty Jones beat. If I was, I would"ve left the gate trying to beat him. I"m

just tired of taking the blame for something I didn"t do."

Chapman was not at all convinced with Bailey"s sincerity.

"How often do you use a stick on the backside?," he asked Bailey.

"I tapped my horse on the shoulder," Bailey said. "He"s a lazy horse."

If you want my opinion, Chapman"s right. The more I think about it, the more I believe that Bailey and

Solis went out of their way to get Smarty beat.

After Rock Hard Ten spit the bit halfway down the backside, Solis kept pumping on the obviously tired

animal, and could have done some serious damage to him. Trainer Ormann ripped Solis after the race.

Too bad that Gary Stevens didn"t come back from Europe to ride Rock Hard Ten. I doubt very much that

he would have used the same tactics. And you can only wonder how Pat Valenzuela (Ormann"s next choice)

would have ridden the horse.

As for Bailey, I"ll repeat what I said here last week. I"ve been watching Bailey ride for 20 years, and I had

never before seen him make the suicidal four-wide backside move that he made in the Belmont.

The bottm line is that Belmont Stakes Day, rightly hailed beforehand as the greatest day in modern

American racing, turned into a disaster -- a disaster for the American public, which was geared to make

the popular Smarty Jones the first Triple Crown winner in 26 years; a disaster for the bettors, who

wagered millions on Smarty Jones -- and Eddington and Rock Hard, whom, as the race was run, never

had a chance, and, maybe most significantly -- a disaster for the reputations of superstars Jerry Bailey

and Alex Solis.

Despite all his accomplishments in a brilliant riding career, Bailey will always be remembered as the

guy who took down Smarty Jones.

As a footnote, Bailey for years has been a regular guest on WFAN sports talk radio in New York, so it was

no surprise that afternoon host Mike Francesa took Bailey"s side, and, in fact, put Jerry on the air to

make his case.

At the same time, Francesa spent hours bashing Stewart Elliott. Francesa kept saying that Elliott should

have let Eddington go, and then come back and get him.

This may be the stupidest racing comment I"ve ever heard...and Phil Mushnick, the sports-media

columnist for the New York Post, shares my view.

Mushnick wrote yesterday:

"In bashing Stewart Elliott for a bad ride, Francesa said Elliott should have just let them

(Rock Hard Ten and Eddington) go, he seemed to think that 3-year-old horses are like Ferraris, and jockeys

are like race car drivers...that, together, they can go real fast, brake, then go real fast again."

P.S.: Is is not amazing that I just wrote an entire piece off the Belmont Stakes without once mentioning

the winner?


In case you are thinking that a rematch between Smarty Jones and Birdstone (there, I said it), is in the

immediate future, forget about it. There is what I would call a 50-50 chance that Smarty Jones will make

the Haskell at Monmouth, there is zero chance that Birdstone will.

Going back to the days of Strike the Gold, trainer Zito is anti-Monmouth Park. He has always believed

stretch-runners are at a disadvantage over Monmouth"s tight turns and short stretch. Moreover, New Yorker

Zito clearly will run his horse in the Jim Dandy and Travers at Saratoga, where he is stabled.

Meanwhile, New Jersey racing is prepared to move mountains to get Smarty to race in the Garden State.

If Smarty does not make the Haskell,
Jersey will go so far as to move the dates of the Pegasus and/or the Meadowlands Cup to attract Smarty.

If Smarty as expected goes in the Pennysylvania Derby Sept. 6 at Philadelphia Park, Monmouth has offered

to move the Pegasus -- which has always been run in October at The Meadowlands -- to Sept. 26, closing

day at Monmouth, to position it as a perfect prep for the Breeders" Cup.

You will be reading and hearing often in the next few weeks similar proposals to Get Smarty. And,

obviously, money will be no object.

It"s interesting. Despite his stunning Belmont defeat, Smarty is as popular as ever.

One final thought:

The NTRA is to be commended for getting more racing on TV, but the agency will have to do a better

selling job. The rating for last Saturday"s 90-minute Pick Four program on ESPN was 0.3.

That"s hockey country.

<< Back To Newsletter

Redeeming a gift certificate or promotional certificate? We'll ask for your claim code when it's time to pay.